Credit: iQoncept / Shutterstock
SUSAN BIGELOW
Next week Republican voters go to the polls to choose their candidate to run against US Sen. Richard Blumenthal in the fall election. They are choosing between a good but probably doomed candidate, a consistent but absolutely doomed candidate, and total disaster. What they choose in the primary next week will tell us a lot about whether that very endangered species, the moderate Connecticut Republican, can survive.
On paper it’s such an easy decision. A moderate, well-liked, reasonable candidate with a fantastic resume, former House Minority Leader Themis Klarides, is running against Peter Lumaj, a hard-right conservative, and Leora Levy, who is … a lot.
Lumaj has always been far to the right of most Connecticut voters, and has gone as far to say that the January 6th hearings are a “witch hunt” to prevent Trump from running again in 2024. He’s also a perennial candidate who has a small but devoted core of supporters. To date, he has never won anything.
Levy is running as a pro-gun, anti-abortion, thoroughly Trumpist Republican. She expertly wields Trumpian rhetoric, calling Klarides a creature of the Hartford “swamp,” and was actually nominated by the former president to serve as ambassador to Chile (though her nomination never came up for a vote in the Senate).
But in the past she’s been a pro-choice moderate Romney supporter who bashed Trump and, with her husband, donated money to Richard Blumenthal at one point. If you want to trace her twists and turns, Dan Haar at Hearst has done so very well.
The upshot is that she’s a cynical opportunist who will say and do anything to get into office, including cheerfully abandoning positions and principles she may once have held to embrace frothing-at-the-mouth populist extremism. Sounds familiar, doesn’t it? In short, Peter Lumaj may be a Trump supporter, but Leora Levy is channeling the noxious, decrepit spirit of the man himself.
If you’re an OANN-watching, election-denying, gun-toting, QAnon-believing, gay-hating, right-wing nationalist, you’re absolutely going to love her. Are there enough of this kind of Republican in Connecticut to swing a low-turnout summer primary to Levy?
Oh man. I have no idea. And I’m not looking forward to finding out.
The truth is that nobody knows who is going to show up next Tuesday to vote. Will it be button-down Fairfield County businessmen, religious pro-lifers, or the guys who open carry at the American Steakhouse “just in case”?
If this primary were happening 10 years ago I’d be pretty confident Klarides would win. I still think that’s the most likely outcome. There are enough Republicans left in Connecticut who would rather win an election than be ideologically pure … at least, I think there are. But gross, loud, gleefully bigoted, Trumpian nationalism has warped so many minds on the right that it’s hard to know anymore.
The best reason to vote for Levy is to stick up a big middle finger at everyone and everything right-wing extremists hate, including and especially other conservatives who don’t follow their views. It’s not hard to see that motivating the sort of people who have a collection of “Let’s Go Brandon” bumper stickers to turn out. After all, why have a consistent conservative like Lumaj or an electable moderate like Klarides when you could basically troll the whole state?
After 2016 I remember someone online somewhere saying that Trump voters put him in the White House because they thought it was funny. That’s stuck with me. Nominating Levy would be hilarious, if you think throwing a grenade into a garden party is a laugh riot. So many liberal and RINO tears! Think of the memes!
Oh, sure, they’d lose, but they were going to lose anyway.
What I don’t get is why Klarides is in this race at all. She originally was running for governor, until a last-minute deal of some kind was struck before the GOP convention that cleared the field for Bob Stefanowski and threw her into the wood chipper of national politics. How did the brain trust at Connecticut GOP headquarters look at Stefanowski’s disaster of a 2018 campaign, plus his four subsequent years of developing exactly zero policies, and think, ah, here’s our guy?
Support authentic, locally owned and operated public service journalism!
If I thought them capable of playing chess, I’d say this was a way to keep Klarides in the public eye while Stefanowski lumbers toward getting crushed by Lamont, making it that much easier for her to run for a presumably open seat in 2026. But it’s equally possible that they’re just bad at running a political party.
So which way will Connecticut Republicans go? Will they vote for an admittedly small fighting chance against Blumenthal, or tie a rock to their legs and careen headfirst into Long Island Sound? Your guess is as good as mine.
More about Election 2022
Themis Klarides
Klarides Aims Center, While Republican Opponents Tack Right
Themis Klarides embraced her moderate political leanings as a general election strength during a Tuesday night debate of Republican U.S. Senate hopefuls, which saw opponents Leora Levy and Peter Lumaj compete for the most conservative positions on abortion and gun control.
Keep reading
July 26, 2022, 10:25 pmJuly 27, 2022, 8:42 am
The Connecticut State Capitol in Hartford, shown in January 2020.
8 Debates Announced
In advance of the election in November, Connecticut Public and the League of Women Voters of Connecticut (LWVCT) have scheduled a series of eight debates featuring candidates from races for governor, U.S. Senate, secretary of the state, and the five congressional districts.
Keep reading
U.S. Rep. Jahana Hayes, D-5th (FILE/CTNewsJunkie)
Dems Outpace Republicans in Second Quarter Fundraising
Incumbent Democrats in all five of Connecticut’s congressional districts far outstripped their Republican challengers in the election fundraising quarter that concluded at the end of June, according to federal campaign finance reports. Fundraising was most competitive in the state’s 5th District, where two-term Democrat U.S. Rep. Jahana Hayes brought in roughly $340,000 in contributions, more…
Keep reading
July 25, 2022, 3:40 pmJuly 26, 2022, 1:38 am
OP-ED | The New Political Catchphrase: ‘Parents’ Rights’
As we approach the Connecticut primaries on Aug. 9, the political rhetoric is heating up. In addition to the abundant TV ads, I’ve noticed some increasingly popular language that has been thrown around by many Republican candidates discussing education: parents’ rights, parental choice, or some variation thereof.
Keep reading
July 24, 2022, 11:06 amJuly 24, 2022, 11:27 am
An absentee ballot envelope for West Hartford.
Calling All Primary Voters, Absentee Ballots Are Now Available
Connecticut residents planning to cast votes in party primary elections next month can begin voting this week via absentee ballot, which are more widely available as a result of a new law that eased eligibility restrictions. Democrats and Republicans will head to the polls on Aug. 9 to choose their parties’ nominees in contested local,…
Keep reading
July 20, 2022, 3:00 pmJuly 20, 2022, 1:57 pm
Stephanie Thomas
Thomas: Trust and Transparency Key to Secretary of the State
When she entered the race there were six other people running for the Democratic nomination for secretary of the state. Now it’s down to two. “It was definitely a challenge because it was just when Omicron picked up in prevalence,” Rep. Stephanie Thomas, D-Norwalk, said of the start to her campaign. She couldn’t get out…
Keep reading
Lt. Gov. Susan Bysiewicz
Bysiewicz Takes Aim At Stefanowski In First Campaign Ad
Lt. Gov. Susan Bysiewicz released her first TV ad of the campaign season, touching on abortion rights, gun violence, and taking aim at Republican gubernatorial candidate Bob Stefanowski. The ad opens with a reminder to voters that “elections matter” and that if they re-elect her and Gov. Ned Lamont, then they will protect a women’s…
Keep reading
Republican gubernatorial candidate Bob Stefanowski (CTNewsJunkie file)
What Do Candidates’ Tax Returns Reveal?
Republican gubernatorial candidate Bob Stefanowski said Friday he will release his tax returns by the end of August. “We’re going to actually produce the return, the first couple pages of the return,” Stefanowski said Friday. “It’s going to include all of my income, family income, everything.” Democratic Gov. Ned Lamont released a summary of three…
Keep reading
Bob Stefanowski and Ned Lamont.
OP-ED | Is Businessman Stefanowski Doomed To Repeat History?
While much of the body politic is focused on the congressional midterms and whether President Biden and his predecessor Donald Trump will run for the White House again in 2024, true political junkies in Connecticut have turned their eyes to this year’s gubernatorial election between incumbent Democrat Ned Lamont and Republican challenger, the career businessman…
Keep reading
Republican gubernatorial candidate Bob Stefanowski held a press conference at
a North Branford strip mall Thursday morning, July 14, 2022.
Stefanowski: Lamont Needs To Act To Mitigate Inflation; Says He’ll Make Connecticut More Competitive
NORTH BRANFORD, CT – Republican gubernatorial candidate Bob Stefanowski held a press conference at a North Branford strip mall Thursday morning accusing Gov. Ned Lamont of failing to act against surging inflation and listing actions he says Lamont should take immediately to mitigate the growing impact on state residents.
Keep reading
More from Susan Bigelow
A mostly full CTtransit bus in Hartford on Monday, July 25, 2022.
OP-ED | Want to Strike a Blow Against Climate Change? Make the Buses Free Forever
Connecticut is in the middle of a serious, dangerous heat wave, as is most of the rest of the US. The cause, scientists say, is man-made climate change. But that should be obvious. How can anyone look at a world consumed by wildfires, drought, severe storms, and heat waves and continue to deny that climate…
Keep reading
Screengrab from Dita Bhargava’s latest advertisement in the Democratic Primary for state Treasurer, titled “Stripped Away.”
OP-ED | Dita Bhargava Brings Roe into the Treasurer’s Primary. Will it Work?
A defiant Dita Bhargava, bare-shouldered against a dark background, says she approves this message “for millions of women across America.” A succession of similarly bare-shouldered women, each looking directly at the camera, flashes by. “This is who had freedom over their own bodies stripped away,” Bhargava says. “This is who the Supreme Court left completely…
Keep reading
ANALYSIS | Abortion Politics Heat Up August Legislative Primaries
It’s only one month until the August primary, a date I’m sure you all have circled on your calendars. Yes, there really is nothing like a primary election in early August, when it’s way too hot out and everyone is on vacation. These low-turnout contests have the potential to swing in surprising directions, so over…
Keep reading
Photograph of the Cragin Memorial Library, Colchester, Connecticut.
OP-ED | Stop Using Children to Advance Your Own Bigotry
Pride Month has come to an end, and Colchester First Selectman Andreas Bisbikos decided to celebrate by demanding that a book about RuPaul be pulled from the shelves of the children’s section at the Cragin Memorial Library.
Keep reading
The Pride flag-raising ceremony at Enfield Town Hall in Enfield, Connecticut on June 1, 2022.
OP-ED | Pride Month in the Age of ‘Don’t Say Gay’
Every June, I’m reminded of why it’s such a relief to live in a place like Connecticut. The rainbow Pride flag flies over the Capitol in Hartford, our public officials take part in Pride parades, and the law, in contrast to some other parts of the country, protects LGBTQ people instead of silencing or persecuting…
Keep reading
This Hearst image of then-House Minority Leader Themis Klarides, R-Derby, speaking at a rally for presidential candidate Donald Trump in Bridgeport in April 2016 was included with an Oct. 10, 2016, story headlined “State Republicans mum on Trump.” Klarides was reported saying she would continue to “re-evaluate” Trump on a daily basis but declined to endorse him on Oct. 10, 2016.
ANALYSIS | It’ll Take More than Being Less Popular for Richard Blumenthal to Lose
Sen. Richard Blumenthal winning elections is as much a constant in Connecticut life as complaining about taxes, sitting in traffic, and arguing over pizza joints. He’s been around forever, and he’s always been popular. So what happens if that seemingly ironclad popularity erodes, as a recent Quinnipiac Poll suggests it has? Does that mean, as…
Keep reading